170-174 W Millstream Road, Cream Ridge, NJ 08514 (MLS# 22601419)

170-174 W Millstream Road, Cream Ridge, NJ 08514

$1,450,000

Virtual Tour

https://my.matterport.com/show/?m=L2SKenZcjTQ&mls=1

Main House, new tankless heater and boiler for heat

174-W-Millstream-Rd-Cottage-Bedroom-Defu

174-W-Millstream-Rd-Cottage-Bathroom-Def

174-W-Millstream-Rd-Cottage-Kitchen-Defu

174-W-Millstream-Rd-Cottage-Dining-Room-

Property Type: Residential Bedrooms: 6 Baths: 3.1 Square Footage: 2,468 Lot Size (sq. ft.): 1,306,800 Status: Active

Current Price: $1,450,000 List Date: 1/15/2026 Last Modified: 3/18/2026

Overview

Description

Discover the lifestyle you've been looking for at 170-174 West Millstream Rd—a rare 30-acre preserved farm in beautiful Plumsted Township, perfect for multi-generational living, equestrian use, or those seeking wide-open space with multiple dwellings and flexible use potential. This versatile property features a spacious 4-bedroom, 2-bath split-level main home with a bright sunroom that overlooks the western fields—offering uninterrupted sunset views every evening. Whether you're hosting family or simply enjoying a peaceful morning coffee, the sunroom is a standout space that brings the outdoors in. A separate 2-bedroom, 1.5-bath cottage—currently rented—adds immediate income potential or can serve as an ideal guest house or independent living space for extended family.

Supplements: For even more flexibility, a former 3-bedroom farmhouse/barn remains on-site with the potential to be rebuilt into a new residence, in-law housing, or custom equestrian facility (buyer to perform due diligence). Horse lovers will appreciate the wide-open fields and the ability to add a pole barn and paddock areaperfect for turnout, training, or fu ... (Read more)

Listing Details MLS# 22601419

Contract Info

List Price/SqFt: 587.52
Property Sub-Type: Single Family Residence
Sub-Type: Detached

Location

House Number: 170-174
Dir.: W
Street Name: Millstream
Street Suffix: Road
County: Ocean
Municipality: Plumsted (PLU)
Postal City: Cream Ridge
State: NJ
Zip Code: 08514
Area/Section: None
Complex/Subdivision: None
Other Elementary: New Egypt
Middle School: New Egypt
High School: New Egypt
Other High: New Egypt
Directions: Rte 539 to West Millstream. Sign at end of driveway; continue ALL THE WAY down driveway past blue house....and then keep going. Main house will be to your front; cottage to your right. If you decide to hang a left at any point after you leave West Millstream you're going the wrong way. Cottage to be shown on subsequent showings.

General Property Info

Full Baths: 3
Half Baths: Yes
Total Baths: 3.1
Fireplace: Yes
# Fireplaces: Yes
Apx SqFt: 2468
# Levels: Yes
# Units/Bldgs: 3
Apx Year Built: 1970
Garage: Yes
# Car Garage: 2
Acreage: 30
Capital Contribution: No
HOA: No
Pool: No
Waterfront: No
Waterview: No
Farm: Yes
Rooms: 12
Basement: Yes

Tax and Legal

Asmnt - Total: 547900
Taxes: 19215
Tax Year: 2025

Remarks & Misc

Excluded: Seller's Personal items; tenant's personal items.

Ownership Type

Fee Simple: Yes

More Information

Style

Cottage: Yes
Farmhouse: Yes
Split Level: Yes

Interior

Attic: Yes
Bay/Bow Window: Yes
Beamed Ceilings: Yes
First Floor Bedroom: Yes
French Doors: Yes
Recessed Lighting: Yes
Skylight(s): Yes

Zoning

Agricultural: Yes
Residential: Yes

Showing

Showing Time: Yes

Lot Description

Land Locked: Yes
Level: Yes

Included

Ceiling Fan(s): Yes
Dishwasher: Yes
Dryer: Yes
Fireplace Equipment: Yes
Garage Door Opener: Yes
Hot Tub: Yes
Microwave: Yes
Refrigerator: Yes
Stove: Yes
Washer: Yes
Window Treatments: Yes
Wood Stove: Yes

Water Type

Pond: Yes

Water/Sewer

Septic Tank: Yes
Well: Yes

Floors

Carpet: Yes
Ceramic Tile: Yes
Wood: Yes

Basement

Crawl Space: Yes
Slab: Yes

Great/Family Room

Fireplace - Woodburning: Yes

Cooling

Central Air: Yes
Heat Pump: Yes

Water Heater

Propane Gas: Yes
Tankless: Yes

Out Buildings

Misc Building: Yes
Shed(s): Yes

Heating

Baseboard: Yes
Heat Pump: Yes
Hot Water: Yes
Other: Yes

Exterior

Outbuilding: Yes
Patio: Yes
Shed: Yes

Parking

Concrete: Yes
Driveway: Yes

Garage

Attached: Yes
Direct Access: Yes
Workshop/ Workbench: Yes

Assessment Status

Assessed: Yes

Siding

Vinyl: Yes

Roof

Shingle: Yes
Sloping: Yes

Property Features

Ownership Type: Fee Simple Style: Cottage; Farmhouse; Split Level Interior: Attic; Bay/Bow Window; Beamed Ceilings; First Floor Bedroom; French Doors; Recessed Lighting; Skylight(s) Basement: Crawl Space; Slab Floors: Carpet; Ceramic Tile; Wood Cooling: Central Air; Heat Pump Heating: Baseboard; Heat Pump; Hot Water; Other Water Heater: Propane Gas; Tankless Exterior: Outbuilding; Patio; Shed Garage: Attached; Direct Access; Workshop/ Workbench Siding: Vinyl Roof: Shingle; Sloping Parking: Concrete; Driveway Out Buildings: Misc Building; Shed(s) Included: Ceiling Fan(s); Dishwasher; Dryer; Fireplace Equipment; Garage Door Opener; Hot Tub; Microwave; Refrigerator; Stove; Washer; Window Treatments; Wood Stove Zoning: Agricultural; Residential Lot Description: Land Locked; Level Water Type: Pond Assessment Status: Assessed Showing: Showing Time

Listing Office: Keller Williams Princeton R.E.

Listing Agent: Christopher Norton

Last Updated: March - 18 - 2026

The data relating to real estate on this web site comes in part from the Internet Data Exchange program of the MLS of the Monmouth Ocean Regional REALTORS®, and site contains live data. IDX information is provided exclusively for consumers' personal, non-commercial use and may not be used for any purpose other than to identify prospective properties consumers may be interested in purchasing.